A head-to-head look at two of the top wedges in the Every18 index — scores, fit, estimated used price, and which one to buy.
2018 Wedges
2026 Wedges
The Callaway Mack Daddy 4 edges the Titleist Vokey SM11 on overall Every18 score (95 vs 94), but that headline number only tells part of the story. The Callaway Mack Daddy 4 is both the cheaper buy (about $45 used vs $170) and the stronger value pick, which makes it the safer choice if budget matters. They split the two traits most golfers care about: the Titleist Vokey SM11 is the more forgiving wedges, while the Callaway Mack Daddy 4 is the faster one — so pick the trait your game needs most. Bottom line: choose the Callaway Mack Daddy 4 if you fit its profile (aggressive groove spin); choose the Titleist Vokey SM11 if you lean toward current vokey matrix.
| Metric | Callaway Mack Daddy 4 | Titleist Vokey SM11 |
|---|---|---|
| Every18 score | 95 ✓ | 94 |
| Forgiveness | 72 | 83 ✓ |
| Speed | 84 ✓ | 80 |
| Feel | 84 ✓ | 76 |
| Value rating | 94 ✓ | 69 |
| Est. used price | $45 ✓ | $170 |
| Value index | 253 ✓ | 66 |
| Launch | Mid | Mid |
| Spin | Mid | Mid |
| Fit profile | Aggressive groove spin | Current Vokey matrix |
Scores, value indexes, and prices are Every18 editorial estimates for comparison. Verify exact specifications, configuration, condition, and market price before purchasing.
On the Every18 editorial score the Callaway Mack Daddy 4 rates higher (95 vs 94 out of 100). "Better" still depends on fit — the Callaway Mack Daddy 4 suits aggressive groove spin, while the Titleist Vokey SM11 suits current vokey matrix.
The Callaway Mack Daddy 4 scores higher on the Every18 value index. Estimated used prices are about $45 for the Callaway Mack Daddy 4 and $170 for the Titleist Vokey SM11, so the Callaway Mack Daddy 4 is also the cheaper buy.
The Titleist Vokey SM11 rates higher for forgiveness (83 vs 72), which usually helps mid- and higher-handicap players hold more fairways and greens.
See how these stack up against the rest of the field.
Compare all wedges →* As an Amazon Associate, Every18 earns from qualifying purchases. Some links here are affiliate links — using them costs you nothing extra, and it never affects our course ratings.
* As an Amazon Associate, Every18 earns from qualifying purchases · affiliate links
